Your machine cancel was made by a machine sold by the Columbia Postal Supply Company of Silver Creek, New York. The machines made by this company generate a wide variety of markings. This earlier marking can be confused with those made by other manufacturers: just one of the reasons why this 'machine finder' system was devised.
Sorry, I don't have a picture of this Columbia impression. It would be dated 1906 or later, and have straight-line killer bars taller than 20 mm. If anyone can send me a nice photocopy (or better yet, a scan in TIFF format), I would greatly appreciate it.
There is a bit more information available about these machines on my Machine Web page.
Use the browser BACK button to return to the page that invoked this page!
Return to Start of Machine Cancel Finder
Bob Swanson's Machine Cancel Page
Bob Swanson's Postal History Page
Updated Sun Feb 24 10:13:17 MST 2019